Stop-Loss vs. Stop-Limit Order: Which Order to Use?

Traders and investors who want to limit potential losses can use several types of orders to get into and out of the market at times when they may not be able to place an order manually. Stop-loss orders and stop-limit orders are two tools for accomplishing this. However, it is critical to understand the difference between these two tools.

Stop-Loss Orders

There are two types of stop-loss orders: one to protect long positions (sell-stop order), and one to limit losses on short positions (buy-stop order).

Sell-Stop Orders

Sell-stop orders protect long positions by triggering a market sell order if the price falls below a certain level. The underlying assumption behind this strategy is that, if the price falls this far, it may continue to fall much further. The loss is capped by selling at this price.

For example, let’s say a trader owns 1,000 shares of ABC stock. They purchased the stock at $30 per share, and it has risen to $45 on rumors of a potential buyout. The trader wants to lock in a gain of at least $10 per share, so they place a sell-stop order at $41. If the stock drops back below this price, then the order will become a market order and get filled at the current market price, which may be higher (or quite likely lower) than the stop-loss price of $41. In this case, the trader might get $41 for 500 shares and $40.50 for the rest. But they will get to keep most of the gain.

Buy-Stop Orders

Buy-stop orders are conceptually the same as sell-stop orders. However, they are used to protect short positions. A buy-stop order price will be above the current market price and will trigger if the price rises above that level.

Stop-Limit Orders

Stop-limit orders are similar to stop-loss orders. But as their name states, there is a limit on the price at which they will execute. There are two prices specified in a stop-limit order: the stop price, which will convert the order to a sell order, and the limit price. Instead of the order becoming a market order to sell, the sell order becomes a limit order that will only execute at the limit price or better.

Of course, there is no guarantee that this order will be filled, especially if the stock price is rising or falling rapidly. Stop-limit orders are used in situations where although the price of the stock or other security has fallen below the limit price, the investor does not want to sell at the current low price and is willing to wait for the price to rise back to the limit price.

For example, continuing with the above example, let’s assume ABC stock never drops to the stop-loss price. Instead, it continues to rise and eventually reaches $50 per share. The trader cancels their stop-loss order at $41 and puts in a stop-limit order at $47, with a limit of $45. If the stock price falls below $47, then the order becomes a live sell-limit order. If the stock price falls below $45 before the order is filled, then the order will remain unfilled until the price climbs back to $45.

Many investors will cancel their limit orders if the stock price falls below the limit price because they placed them solely to limit their loss when the price was dropping. Because they missed their chance to get out, they will simply wait for the price to go back up. They may not wish to sell at that limit price at that point, in case the stock continues to rise. 

As with buy-stop orders, buy-stop-limit orders are used for short sales, when the investor is willing to risk waiting for the price to come back down if the purchase is not made at the limit price or better.

Benefits and Risks of Stop-Loss and Stop-Limit Orders

Stop-loss and stop-limit orders can provide different types of protection for investors. Stop-loss orders can guarantee execution, but price fluctuation and price slippage frequently occur upon execution. Most sell-stop orders are filled at a price below the limit price; the difference depends largely on how fast the price is dropping. An order may get filled for a considerably lower price if the price is plummeting quickly.

Stop-limit orders can guarantee a price limit, but the trade may not be executed. This can saddle the investor with a substantial loss in a fast market if the order does not get filled before the market price drops through the limit price. If bad news comes out about a company and the limit price is only $1 or $2 below the stop-loss price, then the investor must hold onto the stock for an indeterminate period before the share price rises again. Both types of orders can be entered as either day orders or good-’til-canceled (GTC) orders.

Choosing which type of order to use essentially boils down to deciding which type of risk is better to take. The first step to doing so is to carefully assess how the stock is trading.

If the stock is volatile with substantial price movement, then a stop-limit order may be more effective because of its price guarantee. If the trade doesn’t execute, then the investor may only have to wait a short time for the price to rise again. A stop-loss order would be appropriate if, for example, bad news comes out about a company that casts doubt upon its long-term future. In this case, the stock price may not return to its current level for months or years (if it ever does). Investors would, therefore, be wise to cut their losses and take the market price on the sale. A stop-limit order may eventually yield a considerably larger loss if it does not execute.

Another important factor to consider when placing either type of order is where to set the stop and limit prices. Technical analysis can be a useful tool here; stop-loss prices are often placed at levels of technical support or resistance. Investors who place stop-loss orders on stocks that are steadily climbing should take care to give the stock a little room to fall back. If they set their stop price too close to the current market price, they may get stopped out due to a relatively small retracement in price. They may also miss out when the price starts to rise again.

The Bottom Line

Stop-loss and stop-limit orders can provide different types of protection for both long and short investors. Stop-loss orders guarantee execution, while stop-limit orders guarantee the price.